Show the exerciseHide the exercise
Convert the chapter's full Brown citation to a named short form for page 495.
Brown, 347 U.S. at 495. The named short form presupposes the earlier full citation and a context in which Brown clearly identifies the intended decision. It preserves reporter identity and the relied-on page while omitting the repeated first page and date. If those assumptions fail in the final document, repeat enough full information to restore clear identification.
Show the exerciseHide the exercise
A full Brown citation to page 495 is followed immediately by a second citation to the same passage and no other authority. Supply the shortest ordinary form and explain its reference.
Id. The immediately preceding citation identifies one source at the same pinpoint, so no new at-page locator is needed. The italicized period belongs to the abbreviation. This form is safe only under the supplied sequence. Any inserted authority, competing source, or changed passage requires rechecking the reference rather than copying the answer mechanically.
Show the exerciseHide the exercise
Brown is followed by an Anderson citation. The next sentence returns to Brown at 495. Repair “Id. at 495.”
Use Brown, 347 U.S. at 495, or repeat Brown's full citation if that improves clarity. The defective Id. would follow Anderson rather than return to Brown. The intervening authority changes the reference even though Brown remains nearby. A named short form solves that identification problem, while the pinpoint still needs to support the sentence.
Show the exerciseHide the exercise
Explain the problem with “Brown, supra, at 495” in an ordinary practitioner citation.
The ordinary case convention uses a named/reporter or permitted id. short form, not supra. Repair it to Brown, 347 U.S. at 495 after clear full identification. Source-specific eligibility matters: a cross-reference appropriate for a book does not automatically work for a case. An introduced short name for a particularly long case name remains a source-specific case short form; it does not make supra appropriate under the taught Indigo baseline.
Show the exerciseHide the exercise
Fictional training example — not legal authority. Your document cites State v. Vale and State v. Harbor. Explain why “State, 12 Fiction Rep. at 8” is a poor named short form, even if you had correctly identified one reporter volume.
Fictional training example — not legal authority.
State is a common governmental party name shared by both decisions, so it does not distinguish the intended authority. Use the distinctive opposing party, additional identifying information, or a full citation as appropriate. The question supplies no complete reporter metadata for a finished answer; do not invent it. Explain how the chosen short name points to one actual earlier full citation.
Show the exerciseHide the exercise
Fictional training example — not legal authority. A footnote cites two different books. The next footnote says Id. and intends the first book. Repair the identification strategy without inventing missing authors or titles.
Fictional training example — not legal authority.
Identify the intended book by its author/short title or repeat its full citation using information actually supplied in the document. Id. after a citation to two works is ambiguous and cannot select the author's preferred first book. Do not manufacture missing names or titles. The repair must make the reference recoverable for a reader, not merely for the writer who remembers the research sequence.
Show the exerciseHide the exercise
Fictional training example — not legal authority. A paragraph moves from after a citation to Report A to after a citation to Report B. Its final Id. was meant to refer to Report A. Describe the audit and correction required.
Fictional training example — not legal authority.
Read the paragraph in its new position and identify the immediately preceding cited source. Because it now follows Report B, replace the intended Report A reference with a clear permitted short form or full citation. Check its pinpoint against Report A again. Paragraph movement can change referential meaning without changing a citation's characters, which is why this audit occurs after structural edits.
Show the exerciseHide the exercise
Explain why using a named short form rather than id. after interruption is described here as a house preference, not as a verified rule of every court.
The house preference chooses a clear name after interruption as an editorial aid to readers and reviewers. It does not purport to report every court's mandatory short-form rule. A receiving instruction may permit or prefer another unambiguous source-specific form. Labeling the preference accurately preserves the distinction between convention, verified local requirement, and optional editorial practice.
Show the exerciseHide the exercise
Fictional training example — not legal authority. Two books have the same author. An earlier full citation identifies each. What additional identifying information might an author-based supra citation need, and what must remain true about its pinpoint?
Fictional training example — not legal authority.
Add a distinguishing short title or repeat sufficient full information so the reader knows which of the author's books is meant. The earlier full citation must remain locatable, and the supplied pinpoint must belong to the identified work and support the new sentence. A surname alone is inadequate when it matches several works. Do not assume identical authors imply identical editions or pagination.
- Previous
- Chapter 5 answers