Skip to content

Answer key

Chapter 12 answers

  1. Solution 12.1

    CC-12-01← Return to Exercise 12.1
    Show the exercise

    Fictional training example — not legal authority.

    Construct the supplied fictional Harbor regulation citation for its signed-application subdivision.

    Fictional training example — not legal authority.

    Harbor Admin. Code tit. 4, § 12.3(b) (2025). The compilation name, title, section, subsection, and edition come from the fictional packet. The pinpoint identifies the signed-application text. It is not a real regulation, and no current federal or state regulatory command is verified by this exercise.

  2. Solution 12.2

    CC-12-02← Return to Exercise 12.2
    Show the exercise

    Fictional training example — not legal authority.

    Repair “The agency eliminated signatures” using only the supplied proposal packet.

    Fictional training example — not legal authority.

    The agency proposed removing the signature requirement in its March 1, 2025 notice; the supplied 2025 code still requires a signature. Attribute the change to the proposal rather than saying it occurred. The packet supplies no final adoption or effective date for a change. Do not invent a final rule to reconcile the draft's stronger claim.

  3. Solution 12.3

    CC-12-03← Return to Exercise 12.3
    Show the exercise

    Construct the citation to the inspected 2024 federal-regulation model's reasonable-modification subdivision. Explain why its section locator differs from the Federal Register final rule's volume/page/date locator, and distinguish the publication and effective dates demonstrated by that Register item.

    28 C.F.R. § 35.130(b)(7)(i) (2024). The title, code, nested section locator, and edition identify the historical regulatory text. The separate Register item is identified by its title, volume 89, first page 31,320, and publication date April 24, 2024. Its first page states June 24, 2024 as the effective date and separately lists compliance dates. A Register page identifies a published document and passage; a C.F.R. section identifies codified text within a title. The two locators and the publication/effective dates are not interchangeable, and these checks describe the historical publications rather than a later compliance assessment.

  4. Solution 12.4

    CC-12-04← Return to Exercise 12.4
    Show the exercise

    Fictional training example — not legal authority. A final rule is published June 1 but states an effective date of August 1. Which two dates should the research record distinguish before analyzing July conduct?

    Fictional training example — not legal authority.

    Distinguish the June 1 publication date and August 1 effective date, then investigate which rule governs the July conduct and whether any relevant transition provisions apply. Publication alone does not prove the new command was operative in July. Preserve both dates and the actual source text instead of inferring applicability from the date the notice became available.

  5. Solution 12.5

    CC-12-05← Return to Exercise 12.5
    Show the exercise

    Fictional training example — not legal authority. An ALJ decision is pending commission review. How should a sentence using its reasoning identify the source's role?

    Fictional training example — not legal authority.

    Attribute the reasoning to the ALJ decision and disclose that commission review is pending under the supplied packet. Do not call it the commission's final holding. Identify the deciding level and actual pinpoint. Any substantive weight or finality conclusion needs the applicable procedural law and status research beyond this citation exercise.

  6. Solution 12.6

    CC-12-06← Return to Exercise 12.6
    Show the exercise

    Explain why an official agency FAQ's URL alone does not prove the legal force of its contents.

    Official origin identifies who issued the page, not automatically whether its contents bind everyone. Determine whether the item is guidance, interpretation, a regulation, an order, or another source type, and inspect the operative authority if the sentence asserts a legal duty. Attribute the FAQ's statement accurately. A valid government URL cannot substitute for status and proposition checking.

  7. Solution 12.7

    CC-12-07← Return to Exercise 12.7
    Show the exercise

    Fictional training example — not legal authority. A regulatory page carries a 2025 edition label and was retrieved in 2026. Which information describes the inspected edition, and why is retrieval still worth recording?

    Fictional training example — not legal authority.

    The 2025 label describes the inspected edition. The 2026 retrieval date records when you accessed that edition and helps reconstruct the research event. Keep the two in separate fields. Later access does not silently update the edition's legal text or establish that it includes every amendment through retrieval.

  8. Solution 12.8

    CC-12-08← Return to Exercise 12.8
    Show the exercise

    Explain how to handle a source-table link that opens a different document from the one named.

    Record the mismatched link, identify the actual document opened, and do not use it as verification of the named authority. Search an appropriate official source for the real item and inspect it before relying on its proposition or pinpoint. Preserve unresolved access limitations. A successful download from the wrong URL is not a successful source check.

  9. Solution 12.9

    CC-12-09← Return to Exercise 12.9
    Show the exercise

    Fictional training example — not legal authority. A notice has proposed text on page 10 and the agency's rationale on page 8. Your sentence describes the rationale. What must the pinpoint and source characterization identify?

    Fictional training example — not legal authority.

    Use the rationale's actual page 8 and characterize it as the agency's explanation in the notice, rather than as proposed regulatory text at page 10. The source identity and status still belong in the citation. A nearby page containing related material is not a substitute for the passage the sentence uses.

Previous
Chapter 11 answers